Lloyd Geering

Disturber of Our Peace

Editorial by Art Dewey
Download the PDF version

From The Fourth R
Volume 28, Issue 5
Sept – Oct 2015
Order this issue

He waka eke noa—
We all are in the canoe—no exceptions.

To think, to write, to speak honestly has never been easy. Moreover, when you begin to ask fundamental questions that is when hell usually breaks loose. Most of us prefer our lives as neat as our scotch. Some may call us “risk-averse” but we know better, counting on our stock portfolios to build and bulge without any fussing on our part. Interruptions to our game plan are merely blips on the screen. When you let your logarithms work things out there is no need to fumble about with unnecessary questions. Sit back and enjoy the ride.

But there are some who can’t sit quietly, enjoying the scintillating images of our life. They dare to turn their backs on our conventional certainties. Indeed, they would wrestle with the very assumptions upon which we define our lives. They call into question what many of us have taken for granted for generations. Why upset the universe? What profit is there in it?

28-5 The Geering AffairLloyd Geering is one of those disturbers of the peace. Indeed, even as he approaches five score in years, he continues to take the wheel. He declares quite innocently that he never intended to cause trouble. But from his earliest academic days he set his eyes on what is true. He moved from mathematics to theology, taking a sharp intellect into the murky woods of the Bible, doctrine, and tradition. He recognized that the world he lived in was not the world in which many people worshipped. He rejected the schizophrenia of so many believers, who devote their faith lives to a pre-Copernican universe, while living in a nuclear age. He refused to compartmentalize his faith for the sake of keeping things on an even keel. He could not overlook the findings of science that had shattered the three-tiered universe. In short, he wanted to think honestly.

But honesty often carries a cost. What was for Geering a sustained engagement with the trenchant thinkers of the twentieth century proved prophetic for many. Yet it raised the hackles of others who saw in his work the seeds of heresy and ecclesial destruction. One person’s prophet is another’s heretic. Fortunately, the ecclesial boards demonstrated a balance not always found in such situations. Geering was sustained not only in his efforts but also in providing a critical focus for asking fundamental questions.

Geering has long recognized that, if the Christian tradition is to move into the future, it must be translated. That means that what many assume to have been settled is now quite up in the air. His entire career has reminded the churches that reformation is not a done deal but rather a never-ending challenge, that the very basics of the Christian tradition are at best problematic. They can no longer be taken for granted to insure sonorous sermons.

From early on Geering realized that time and space not only have been reimagined, but also form a new context for reading our ancient traditions. We cannot think in dualistic terms any longer, for we are embedded in this evolutionary experiment. As the Maoris advise, “We all are in the canoe—no exceptions!” But if that is so, what does resurrection mean in such a universe? What happens to our sense of reality when we admit that we are all truly mortal without any mythical escape hatches? Where does hope go, when the medieval paradise comes tumbling down?

Geering does not provide his readers with an easy way out. Instead, he urges us to be human to the end. But is that not the hardest task? It means that we must begin to recognize the telling limits of our life. It entails realizing that our religious traditions are human constructions and are not assured prospects of the future. We are in the midst of something without any idea how it will end. Perhaps this is the most daunting knowledge: that we shall die not knowing how things will eventually go.

Is this not what it means to be human? Yet Geering does not leave us abandoned. Rather, he makes the case that we look about and see what is in our midst. Hope grows not out of some prefabricated future but from the depths of our genuine relationships with one another and with the earth. What we have in the past longed for was a selfish extension of our egos, writ large upon the heavens. What we can truly discover is the mystery of life still aborning in the here and now. Our unfinished existence gives us the opportunity to see that we need one another to make sense of this world. We have yet to exhaust the reality of such a planetary insight. In fact, we can draw on our sacred traditions, as well as our science, to come to grips with our situation.

Geering has been called a heretic as well as a prophet. But he really belongs to another sort. He has betrayed himself by the company he keeps. He has spent much time with the author of Ecclesiastes and has revisited the sayings of Jesus. He has continued to plumb “what you treasure is your hearts true measure” He finds that hope comes from the surprise of love beyond our comfort zones. He detects beauty in the mess of our lives. He notes what Jesus called God’s effective presence in the subtle fusion of our colliding lives. He sees in those delicate, uncertain steps we take together a pathway to our planet’s future. He truly is a sage for our time.

Arthur J. Dewey (Th.D., Harvard University) is Professor of Theology at Xavier University in Cincinnati. A distinguished teacher, writer, translator and commentator, he is the author of Inventing the Passion: How the Death of Jesus was Remembered (forthcoming 2017) and co-author of The Complete Gospel Parallels (with Robert J. Miller, 2011) and The Authentic Letters of Paul (with Roy W. Hoover, Lane C. McGaughy, and Daryl D. Schmidt, 2010). Dewey’s poetry has appeared in Christian Century and his poetic perspective aired on the Saturday Morning Edition on Public Radio Station WVXU (91.7) in Cincinnati for more than a dozen years.

Browse Related Articles


Christianity at the Crossroads

Lloyd Geering

Christianity stands today at a critical point in its long and complex history. Too few Christians realise that humankind is moving into an increasingly global and secular future. Christianity and all other religions must now come to terms with this new global context. Continue reading


Who Owns the Holy Land?

Lloyd Geering

Over the last thirty-five years I have visited all the Middle Eastern countries from Egypt to Iran, some of them many times. This background has shown me that the Holy Land has probably witnessed more violent conflict in the last four thousand years than any other spot in the whole world. Continue reading